Natural Bar Soap vs. Body Wash: Pros And Cons | Soap.Club

Posted on January 30 2017

Natural bar soap vs. liquid hand soap - Soap.Club


Bar Hand Soap, Liquid Soap, Sanitizers, and Keeping Your Hands Clean

Keeping your hands free from harmful viruses and contaminants is a great thing to do if a cold comes into your community and if yours worsens. You must use a proper hand washing technique and the best hand soap.

Hand washing is a critical step in preventing the spread of disease and keeping hands clean. While liquid soap, natural bar hand soaps and sanitizers are all effective, each option has its own pros and cons. It’s essential to be aware of these differences before choosing which product is right for you.


Table of Contents

What To Know Before Buying Hand Sanitizer?

Hand sanitizers can be a great option when you cannot access soap and water or do not have the time to wash your hands properly. However, it is essential to note that not all hand sanitizers are created equal.

There are some key points to look out for before buying:

- Look for an alcohol-based hand sanitizer with at least 60% alcohol content.

- Make sure the product has been approved.

- Avoid scented products as they may contain fragrances that could irritate the skin.

- Always read labels carefully before purchasing a product to ensure it meets your needs and expectations.

Considering these factors, you can decide which hand sanitizer product is right for you.

Proper hand washing with hand soap bars and water is highly recommended as it offers a more thorough cleanse than hand sanitizers alone.

With the pandemic, it has become increasingly important to keep your hands clean and practice good hygiene to help protect yourself and others from getting sick.


 Washing hands with natural bar soap - Soap.Club

Soap.Club can provide you with quality hand bar soaps that will help ensure this happens every time! Shop now to get started on keeping your hands healthy today!


Reasons Why People Switch To Natural Bar Hand Soap:

Although liquid body wash can be beneficial in some cases, natural bar hand soap definitely offers many advantages.

It's essential to consider the pros and cons when making your decision.

- Natural hand soap is free from harsh detergents

- Natural bar soaps are often made with nourishing oils and butters that help to moisturize the skin

- Most natural hands soaps are also biodegradable, making them a better choice for the environment

- You can find bar hand soap in various scents and colors, suitable for every preference

- Hand soap is budget-friendly compared to liquid soaps


Natural bar hand soaps - Soap.Club

Soap.Club has a wide selection of natural hand soaps that are perfect for all your cleaning needs! Shop now to find the perfect solution for you!


Natural Bar Hand Soap Is Luxurious With Shea Butter And Other Natural Oils

The rich history of hand soap bars adds the appeal that liquid body wash can never match; used for thousands of years and perfected over time, bar hand soap has become something of a luxury after years of honing and tweaking.

Liquid hand soap may seem equal to cold process soap in terms of fragrance, but the scent alone can be deceiving. Check the label and see if you would instead put artificial fragrances on your body or pure essential oils.

Most natural bar hand soap is made from olive oil, coconut oil, hemp oil, shea butter, aloe vera, and a blend of essential oils, layered and infused with herbs and salts for a tactile experience.


The Cleanest Feeling Even For Sensitive Skin

Nothing beats that clean, fresh post-shower feeling and achieves the same sense of accomplishment quite like solid hand soap. With bar soap, you gain the satisfaction of scrubbing away dirt and dead skin cells – a feeling that can’t be matched by smoothing shower gel or liquid soap on your skin.

Moreover, bar hand soap is often infused with smoothing particles like ground oats or other natural exfoliators that you can feel working to refresh and revitalize your skin. Many people started using bar soap again because liquid soap left their skin dry and itchy.

An olive oil bar soap with shea butter and aloe vera always keep your skin soft, smooth, and younger-looking, to name just one of its many benefits, and it's suitable for all skin types, including sensitive skin.


Environmentally Responsible

The environment is a crucial issue at the forefront of modern society’s collective mind, and almost everyone accepts that they need to do their bit to care for the planet.

Commercial hand soap and liquid body wash use a variety of chemicals and preservatives that can harm the environment. Read the label and see what you are washing down the drain every day.

Compare the amount of packaging used for liquid soap, and you’ll notice that most natural handmade soap uses less packaging. Many artisans try to use recycled materials and minimal packaging. It is much better to use recycled materials to recycle again instead of using plastic bottles that can take up to 450 years (yes, you read that right!) to decompose in a landfill.


Unrivaled Choice

Bar soap comes in all shapes, sizes, scents, and textures, creating enormous, unrivaled appeal. Handmade soaps are great for gifts; many are colorful or incorporate novelty elements to amuse or entertain.

There is a wide range to choose from, such as transparent soaps, hot or cold process soaps, and aromatherapy soaps, that you’ll never feel restricted by choice.

 Liquid hand and body wash

Solid Bar Soap Is Pretty Perfect

When it comes to liquid soap, there is little that can be done to add aesthetic appeal other than to perhaps incorporate shimmering flecks or beads in the soap.

Solid natural bar soap offers many ways to make products easy on the eyes. Layering different colors or fragrances, pressing raw ingredients to the top layer, creating swirls, and even whipping into a mousse – solid soap is much more versatile regarding aesthetics.


A Thoughtful And Unique Gift

What do you buy for someone who has everything? A bar of handmade natural soap needn’t break the bank, but it can be a thoughtful gift, especially if you know what sort of scents and colors the recipient likes.

Handing over a bottle of liquid soap doesn’t quite stack up in the same way; solid bar soap can be beautiful, sublimely scented, and used in various ways, such as to add fragrance to linen in drawers or as a welcoming treat in your guest bathroom.

And if it's someone special, what about a Monthly natural bar soap membership where the recipient can select their favorite soap fragrances, colors, and exfoliants? Or even fragrance-free?


How Does Soap Work? - via BrainStuff


Now that you know why natural solid bar soap beats liquid body wash, hands down, why not have a go at whipping up your own homemade soap? Please look at our recipe below for a truly indulgent, good enough-to-eat cold process soap.

Alternatively, visit our Scent Store and feast your eyes on our Mint Chocolate Indulgence natural bar hand soap.


Minty Milk Chocolate Cold Process Soap Recipe


22 oz olive oil
8 oz coconut oil
1 oz castor oil
12 oz milk (any you choose)
4.3 oz lye
3 tbsp peppermint essential oil
2 tsp cocoa powder


    Rubber gloves
    Safety goggles
    Large stainless steel or enamel pot
    Wooden or plastic soap mold
    Weighing scales
    Hand stick blender
    Two three qt size plastic pitchers
    Two thermometers
    Two wooden spoons
    Measuring cup, two or three-cup size
    Freezer paper
    An old blanket or large rag
    Piece of cardboard cut to fit the mold as a lid


      1. Milk-based soap needs to be as cold as possible – it’s best to measure the milk and put it in the freezer the day before making the soap.

      2. When the milk is cold, remove it from the freezer, tip it into one of your pitchers, gather your other ingredients, and line your soap mold with freezer paper.

      3. Put on your protective gloves and goggles and weigh out the lye into one of your pitchers. Bit by bit, add it to the milk, stirring continuously until dissolved. Set the mixture to one side.

      4. Measure out the coconut oil, castor oil, and olive oil and reserve a couple of teaspoons to mix with the cocoa powder separately.

      5. Pour the remaining oils into your enamel pot and combine. Slowly add the lye mixture and stir with your stick blender. Alternate with the motor on and off to prevent air bubbles.

      6. When you reach trace, which is when the mixture starts leaving tracks, add the peppermint oil and stir for a minute longer.

      7. Mix the cocoa powder with the reserved oil and swirl in. You can either mix entirely for a solid light brown shade or stir in and leave the swirl tracks for effect.

      8. Pour the soap batter into the lined mold and cover it with the cardboard lid and blanket. Leave to stand for about 18 hours.

      9. Remove the blanket and lid and let the soap air on an open drying rack for between four and six weeks.




      Is it better to use body wash or bar soap?

      It depends on personal preference. Bar soap is generally more cost-effective, can last longer, and is better for the environment. Most bar soaps contain natural ingredients that are gentle on the skin.

      Body wash usually contains more active ingredients, which may be more beneficial depending on your skin type.

      What are the disadvantages of using liquid body wash?

      Body wash may contain ingredients that can dry out the skin, so choosing a product specifically designed for your skin type is essential. Additionally, body washes are usually more expensive than bar soaps and can be wasteful as they come in plastic packaging.

      Are handmade soaps better?

      Yes. Handmade bar soaps are typically made with natural ingredients and essential oils, making them more gentle on the skin. Additionally, handmade soaps are generally free from synthetic fragrances and preservatives that can be harsh on sensitive skin. They often come in beautiful packaging, a great way to add a special touch to your bath routine.

      What other ingredients are used in soap?

      Many soaps contain natural ingredients such as coconut oil, cocoa butter, shea butter, essential oils, and plant-based extracts. These ingredients help to nourish the skin and create a luxurious lather when in contact with water. Additionally, some soaps may contain synthetic fragrances and preservatives for added scent and shelf life.


      Natural bar hand soap - Soap.Club


      Is liquid soap more hygienic than bar soap?

      No. Both liquid and bar soaps are equally hygienic when used correctly. This means washing hands for at least 20 seconds with warm water, lathering the soap between your palms, and rinsing thoroughly.

      Are natural soaps better for the environment?

      Yes. Natural soaps are usually packaged in paper or biodegradable materials, which makes them a better choice when compared to synthetic soaps that often come in plastic packaging. Additionally, natural ingredients used in handmade soaps do not contain chemicals, artificial fragrances, or colors that can harm the environment.

      Can you use bar soap to wash your hands?

      Yes, bar soap can be used to wash your hands. The same procedure should be followed as when using liquid soap: wet the bar with warm water and lather between palms for at least 20 seconds before rinsing thoroughly.

      Can natural soaps cause skin irritation?

      No, natural soaps do not typically cause skin irritation.


      Washing Up In Conclusion

      Making your own soap is a fun, creative, and rewarding activity that anyone can do. With the right ingredients and knowledge, you can create beautiful soaps with unique scents that are gentle on your skin.

      Natural bar soaps are an eco-friendly alternative to body washes and liquid soaps, and they come in incredibly unique packages that can make your bath routine truly special. With the right ingredients, you’ll be able to create a homemade soap that is perfect for your skin type and leaves you feeling refreshed and renewed.

      If you have any questions or need more information about natural soap making, feel free to contact us at!


      Natural bar hand soaps - Soap.Club


      Soap.Club ingredient disclaimer

      Please give us your feedback. We would love to hear for you. Inspired by Jan’s recipe at


      You can learn more about our products on our blog here or just click on the links below:

      25 Amazing Uses and Benefits of Hemp Seed Oil

      15 Amazing Benefits of Shea Butter Soap

      How To Use Essential Oil For Soap Making

      How To Make Pure White Natural Soap From Goat Milk Recipe

      Benefits Of Cold Process Soap-Making

      Molding Soap: The Best (And Inexpensive) Soap Molds

      Top 10 Women's Soap

      Best Organic Soap Base: Our Complete Guide To Using Melt-and-Pour Soaps

      Coconut Oil Benefits in Soap: Skin Nourishing Qualities

      Soap Calculators: Lye Soap Recipes, SAP Values, and Formulations

      Aloe Vera Soap: A Step-By-Step Guide To Make Soap At Home

      Monthly Natural Soap Memberships: Best Soap Subscription of 2022

      Tips for Choosing the Best Bar Soap for Your Skin

      Natural Acne Remedies: 11 Effective Home Treatments: Part One

      Pin It

      Recent Posts